Better Than Sex Desserts Key West - Intimate Dessert Dining

Better Than Sex Desserts Key West is an adults-only dessert and cocktail restaurant at 926 Simonton Street, just one block off Duval Street in Old Town. Open Wednesday through Sunday from 6:00 pm to 11:00 pm, this intimate after-dinner spot turns dessert into the main event with award-winning sweets, signature rimmed drinks, candlelight, velvet curtains, and a speakeasy-style setting built for date nights, anniversaries, birthdays, honeymoons, girls’ nights, and memorable Key West celebrations.

The menu focuses on house-made desserts and indulgent pairings, including favorites such as Peanut Butter Perversion, Missionary Crisp, Cookie Nookie Pie, Man Flowers, Between My Red Velvet Sheets Cheesecake, and Berry Bondage. Signature drinks feature chocolate or caramel-rimmed glasses, adding a playful finishing touch to dessert wines, cocktails, and nightcap pairings.

The Key West dining room has limited seating, with 20 tables designed mainly for couples and small parties of up to four adults. Walk-ins are welcome when space allows, but reservations are suggested on weekends and during special events. For current menu selections and reservation availability, use the Menu and Reservations buttons above.