Mr. Z’s Key West – Philly Cheesesteaks & Late-Night Pizza

Mr. Z’s Key West brings authentic Philadelphia-style cheesesteaks, New York-style pizza, stromboli, hoagies, salads, cheese fries, and late-night comfort food to 501 Southard Street in Old Town Key West. Serving the island since 2002, this casual counter-service restaurant gives visitors a dependable stop for hot sandwiches, foldable pizza, quick takeout, delivery, and after-hours food close to Duval Street, Caroline Street, and the Old Town nightlife scene.

The menu is built around Northeast favorites with a Key West late-night following. Cheesesteaks are served on Amoroso rolls with chopped steak, fried onions, mushrooms, homemade American cheese sauce, Cheese Whiz, or sharp provolone. Guests can also order chicken cheesesteaks, buffalo chicken sandwiches, roast pork Italiano with broccoli rabe and sharp provolone, chicken parmesan, homemade meatball sandwiches, Italian hoagies, ham and cheese hoagies, and turkey hoagies.

Pizza choices include traditional New York-style cheese and pepperoni pies, slices, tomato pie with provolone and San Marzano tomato sauce, white pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, roasted veggie pizza, meatball pizza, cheesesteak pizza, and chicken cheesesteak pizza. Stromboli options include Italian, cheesesteak, American, and veggie four-cheese versions, baked fresh to order. Cheese fries, French fries, Caesar salad, wedge salad, Mrs. Z Salad, bottled drinks, and canned soft drinks round out the menu.

For visitors looking for late-night pizza in Key West, a real Philly cheesesteak, or a quick casual meal after exploring Old Town, Mr. Z’s offers a straightforward, local favorite with limited seating, easy online ordering, pickup, and delivery.