Prime Steakhouse Key West - Premier Steak & Seafood

Prime Steakhouse Key West delivers a polished fine dining experience at 951 Caroline Street, located above Dante’s near Conch Harbor Marina in Old Town Key West. Known for USDA prime steaks, fresh seafood, Florida lobster, classic steakhouse service, and a warm casual-elegant atmosphere, this Caroline Street restaurant is a strong choice for date nights, celebrations, business dinners, and visitors looking for one of Key West’s premier steak and seafood destinations.

The menu centers on expertly charbroiled steaks, including filet mignon, New York strip, porterhouse, Delmonico, bone-in ribeye, and surf & turf with Florida lobster tail. Seafood selections include fresh catch of the day, broiled twin Florida lobster tails, jumbo lump crab cakes, Gulf oysters, sesame encrusted tuna tataki, and chef-selected nightly specials. Signature starters, rich sides, martinis, cocktails, and a curated wine list with selections from the United States, Italy, and France round out the experience.

Guests can dine in the intimate indoor dining room or enjoy the outdoor terrace setting near the marina. Dinner is served nightly from 5:30 pm to 10:00 pm, and reservations are recommended.