Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House Key West - Surf & Turf Dining

Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House Key West: Signature Surf & Turf Dining on Simonton Street

Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House stands proudly at 1007 Simonton Street, defining classic Key West dining with hearty portions, coastal flavors, and a relaxed steakhouse atmosphere. Known as a premier Key West surf and turf restaurant, this longstanding favorite draws crowds for broiled lobster tails, hand-cut steaks, and seafood dishes that spotlight the island’s maritime heritage. Warm lighting, nautical décor, and attentive service turn both casual lunches and celebratory dinners into memorable Old Town experiences.

The menu introduces indulgence from the first bite, featuring coastal appetizers that blend comfort with island personality. The Crab Cake Trio delivers golden crispness with a tangy remoulade, while Conch Fritters paired with a bold Key Lime mustard bring an unmistakable taste of the Florida Keys. For lighter beginnings, a seafood-forward Caesar or chilled seafood salad highlights fresh daily catches layered over vibrant greens.

Duffy’s reputation is built on its celebrated surf-and-turf entrées. The broiled Florida Lobster Tail remains a favorite, its sweet meat paired with rich drawn butter and a squeeze of lemon. Steak enthusiasts savor hand-cut selections such as the flame-kissed Ribeye with house teriyaki glaze or the tender Filet Mignon cooked to perfection. The slow-roasted Prime Rib—carved into generous portions—melts at the touch of a fork. For those craving coastal decadence, the Maine Lobster stuffed with crabmeat delivers a double-dose of ocean richness.

Pasta lovers gravitate toward Jumbo Shrimp Scampi, featuring plump shrimp in garlic white-wine butter over tender linguini. Every entrée is rounded out with classic steakhouse finishings, including a choice of soup or salad, freshly baked bread, and traditional sides like baked potatoes, seasoned rice, or steamed vegetables—ensuring a fully satisfying plate without add-ons.

From drawn-butter lobster to boldly seasoned steaks, Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House remains a staple for visitors seeking authentic Key West flavor in the heart of Old Town. Whether toasting with crisp white wine at the bar or enjoying a memorable family dinner, this Simonton Street standout continues to uphold a reputation built on generous portions and coastal-meets-classic cuisine.