Antonia's Restaurant

Antonia’s: The Best Italian Restaurant in Key West for Handmade Pasta & Fine Wine

For over 30 years, Antonia’s has been a cornerstone of Italian dining in Key West, serving handmade pasta, premium meats, and fresh local seafood in a charming Old Town setting. Located on Duval Street, this highly acclaimed Italian restaurant is celebrated for its commitment to tradition, featuring house-made fettuccine, linguine, and gnocchi, all paired with expertly crafted sauces. Whether indulging in classic veal osso buco, savoring the rich flavors of mushroom fettuccine, or enjoying a simple yet elegant caprese salad, every dish reflects authentic Italian craftsmanship.

The restaurant’s award-winning wine list, recognized by Wine Spectator, showcases an impressive selection of Old and New World wines, offering the perfect pairing for every meal. Antonia’s also embraces the spirit of Italian dining with braciole Sundays, a beloved tradition that keeps guests returning for more.

With accolades from Travel + Leisure Magazine and Frommer’s Travel Guide, Antonia’s delivers an inviting atmosphere where the laid-back charm of Key West meets refined Italian flavors. To complete the experience, house-made desserts like tiramisu provide a decadent finale to an unforgettable meal.

Reserve a table at Antonia’s today and experience why many consider it the best Italian restaurant in Key West.