Thirsty Mermaid Key West Seafood & Raw Bar on Fleming St

Thirsty Mermaid brings fresh local seafood, raw bar favorites, rotating oysters, craft beer, wine, and relaxed nautical-style dining to 521 Fleming Street in Old Town Key West. Located just a short walk from Duval Street, this seafood restaurant gives visitors a polished but approachable place for lunch, happy hour, dinner, oysters, chilled seafood, and fresh coastal plates.

The menu focuses on fresh local catch, seasonal seafood, raw bar selections, and creative dishes prepared with quality ingredients. Guests can enjoy rotating oysters, chilled seafood options, Yellowfin tuna, crackling calamari, lobster empanadas, seafood salads, Key West pink shrimp, scallops, fresh fish preparations, burgers, and other coastal favorites. The raw bar and seafood-forward menu make Thirsty Mermaid a strong choice for visitors looking for oysters, fresh fish, wine, craft beer, and an elevated casual dining experience away from the busiest Duval Street crowds.

Open daily from 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm, Thirsty Mermaid offers a comfortable setting for midday seafood, early evening drinks, happy hour bites, and dinner in the heart of Key West. The restaurant’s combination of fresh seafood, rotating oysters, approachable service, and Fleming Street location makes it a useful stop for visitors exploring Old Town before or after shopping, galleries, nightlife, and nearby attractions. Reservations and current menu details are available by calling (305) 204-4828 or visiting the restaurant’s official website.