Old Town Mexican Cafe - Key West Mexican Restaurant

Old Town Mexican Cafe brings authentic Mexican cuisine, Southwest-inspired dishes, coastal Key West flavors, tequila, mezcal, margaritas, tacos, patio dining, happy hour, lunch, and dinner to 609 Duval Street in the heart of Old Town Key West. Since 1999, this Duval Street Mexican restaurant has welcomed locals and visitors with bold flavors, tropical atmosphere, indoor air-conditioned dining, and a lively garden-style patio made for relaxed island dining.

The menu blends traditional Mexican favorites with creative Southwestern and coastal touches. Guests can enjoy tableside-style guacamole, tacos, enchiladas, fajitas, burritos, quesadillas, carne adovada, molcajete specialties, seafood dishes, fresh fish preparations, steak, lobster, shrimp, vegetarian choices, vegan options, gluten-free selections, and house desserts. Taco Tuesday adds extra appeal with $4 tacos available all day.

Old Town Mexican Cafe is also one of Key West’s standout tequila and mezcal destinations, featuring more than 200 agave selections for margaritas, tastings, and sipping. Daily Happy Hour Fiesta specials from 4:00 pm to 6:00 pm include half-price appetizers, beer specials, wine, sangria, margaritas, and house liquor specials, making it a strong Duval Street stop before dinner or an easy late-afternoon break while exploring Old Town.