Mystic Lobster Roll Company

335 Duval St Ste B, Key West, FL 33040


Mystic Lobster Roll Company

Location: 335 Duval St Ste B, Key West FL 33040-6579, United States

Open Hours: 12:00 PM - 11:10 PM

Ready for Pickup: 19 - 29 min

Featured Items:

  • Classic Rolls: All rolls come with slaw & pickle. Gluten free roll available for an additional charge. Make it a Mighty Mystic and get 50% more lobster for an additional $10.00 or a Monster Mystic and get 100% more lobster for an additional $19.00!
  • Specialty Rolls: All rolls come with slaw & pickle. Gluten free roll available for an additional charge.
  • Tacos: 2 tacos per order. Flour tortillas. Choose from fresh Maine lobster, snow crab, or shrimp.
  • Specialty Items:
    • White Cheddar Mac & Cheese: Choose plain, bacon, or Maine lobster. $16.99
    • Bacon Maine Lobster Bites (5): Served with a honey chipotle sauce. $18.99
  • Kids' Menu:
    • White Cheddar Mac & Cheese: Choose from chicken or Maine lobster. $9.99
    • Chicken Fingers: Kids chicken tenders with a side of waffle fries. $10.99
  • Sides:
    • Side of Slaw & Pickle: $1.49
    • Lobster Bisque or Shrimp & Corn Chowder: 12 oz. $11.99
  • Drinks: Refreshing Beverages

Join us for an unforgettable lobster roll experience! Visit us today at Mystic Lobster Roll Company, Key West.

Mystic Lobster Roll in Key West!

OUR STORY: Mystic Lobster Roll Company began almost 30 years ago when a young 21-year-old minor league baseball player was working in restaurants to make extra money. After his career ended, he found himself deeply immersed in the restaurant industry, taking his passion for sports into his new love—the restaurant business.

Early on, I had the privilege of working for some amazing chefs, including a Michelin star chef. In the summer of 1993, I traveled up and down the Northeast coast from Connecticut to the tip of Maine, experiencing the most amazing lobster rolls I’d ever had. For the next 25 years, I worked at high-profile restaurants and owned a few myself, always including our delicious lobster rolls on the menu but never finding the perfect moment to showcase them fully.

In February 2020, we discovered beautiful Ship Bottom, New Jersey, and knew it was the ideal place to start Mystic Lobster Roll Company. Our lobster rolls gained instant popularity, leading to rapid growth and four locations. Our goal is for everyone to experience a true Maine lobster roll. We strive for perfection, using only the best and freshest Maine cold water lobster meat. Join us and become part of the Mystic Lobster Roll family!

Mystic Lobster Roll Company - Bringing the Authentic Taste of Maine Lobster Rolls to Key West!