Mr. Z’s Key West: Legendary Cheesesteaks, Pizza, and Late-Night Eats
Since 2002, Mr. Z’s has been a go-to Key West eatery serving up Philadelphia-style cheesesteaks, New York-inspired pizza, and hearty strombolis that keep both locals and visitors coming back for more. Founded by Navy veteran Mike Zielinski, this casual spot on 501 Southard Street has built a reputation for delivering bold flavors and generous portions—especially when hunger hits after dark.
Open until 1:00 AM on weekdays and 4:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays, Mr. Z’s is a late-night haven offering a satisfying menu of hot sandwiches, Italian hoagies, and specialty pies. Their cheesesteaks—made with chopped ribeye and your choice of American cheese, sharp provolone, or Cheese Whiz—are a fan favorite. The menu also features chicken cheesesteaks, roast pork with broccoli rabe, and breaded chicken parmesan sandwiches. For something cold, hoagies stacked with Italian meats or turkey and provolone deliver that Northeastern deli experience.
The pizza menu includes traditional cheese pies, bold creations like Buffalo Chicken and Cheesesteak pizzas, and the unique Tomato Pie, a Philly classic built with San Marzano sauce and provolone. Stromboli fans can dig into cheesy, oven-baked rolls filled with steak, Italian meats, or roasted veggies with four cheeses. Rounding out the menu are cheese fries, classic French fries, and plenty of combo options available.
