5 Brothers Key West - Authentic Cuban Sandwiches & Café

5 Brothers Grocery & Sandwich Shop – Authentic Cuban Eats in Old Town Key West

For nearly fifty years, 5 Brothers Grocery & Sandwich Shop has stood at the corner of Southard and Grinnell as a cornerstone of everyday life in Old Town. Family-run since 1978, this compact market continues to supply the island’s community with traditional Cuban comfort food, signature sandwiches, and bold island-style coffee that fuels early mornings from 6:30 AM to 3:00 PM, Monday through Saturday.

The aroma of authentic Café con Leche steams through the doorway before sunrise, enticing regulars and first-timers alike. Classic pan Cubano and guava pastries accompany the morning rush, followed by a steady wave of Cuban toast and breakfast sandwiches pressed to perfection.

By midday, the line forms for legendary Cuban Mix sandwiches, layered with citrus-marinated pork, ham, Swiss, pickles, mustard, aioli, and crisp lettuce and tomato, all sealed with a hot press that crackles as it’s served. A sweet twist appears in the Midnight sandwich on pillowy, slightly sweet bread, while other favorites include steak and onions, roast beef, and a flavorful veggie press made for heavy cravings.

Hot plates rotate Monday through Saturday, featuring traditional Cuban home-style meals such as ropa vieja, picadillo, chicken fricassee, and occasional oxtail or grouper paired with rice and a choice of yuca or sweet plantains. House snacks complete the experience with empanadas, ham croquettes, papa rellenas, conch fritters, and yuca fries fried to golden perfection. Guava-and-cheese pastries provide a sweet finish with just the right amount of indulgence.

Beyond the food, the shop functions as a daily meeting place where locals gather outside on the wood bench, sipping coffee before the sun fully rises. Inside, guests find a curated selection of Cuban staples, spices, pantry items, guava products, and branded merchandise, keeping the legacy alive through every sip, bite, and souvenir.

Location: 930 Southard Street, Key West, FL
Hours: Monday–Saturday 6:30 AM–3:00 PM, Closed Sundays