Eaton Street Seafood Market - Best Key West Seafood Market

Eaton Street Seafood Market brings fresh local seafood, casual seafood dining, takeout, delivery, and nationwide seafood shipping to 801 Eaton Street in historic Old Town Key West. This dual-purpose seafood market and restaurant is a strong stop for visitors looking for lobster rolls, fresh fish sandwiches, shrimp tacos, stone crab when available, seafood baskets, ceviche, smoked fish dip, and Florida Keys seafood prepared simply and fresh.

The menu highlights hot or cold Maine lobster rolls, house-made crab cake sandwiches, fish sandwiches, shrimp sandwiches, fish or shrimp tacos, fresh fish plates, Key West pink shrimp plates, fried seafood baskets, conch strips, conch ceviche, stone crab artichoke dip, smoked fish dip, seafood salads, sides, beer, and wine. Guests can enjoy casual open-air seating, order food to go, or use local delivery when available.

Inside the market, visitors can shop fresh catches from Florida Keys and Key West waters, including grouper, snapper, hogfish, lobster, stone crab in season, Key West pink shrimp, and other fresh seafood favorites. Staff can help with cooking suggestions and market services such as steaming shrimp or lobster, splitting lobster tails, cracking stone crab claws, and preparing seafood for easy take-home meals. Eaton Street Seafood Market is especially useful for visitors planning a casual lunch, easy dinner, vacation rental seafood night, boat-day meal, or fresh seafood shipment after returning home.