Casual Restaurants

Eaton Street Seafood Market

Eaton Street Seafood Market sells fresh local fish, stone crab and Key West pink shrimp in Old Town, cooks your pick on-site and ships nationwide.

Eaton Street Seafood Market

About the market

The catch, straight off the boat.

Eaton Street Seafood Market occupies an 1877 building at the corner of Eaton and William in historic Old Town. Owned by Capt. Damon Santelli and Sean B. Seaman, it’s been called the “Shangri-La” of Key West’s local seafood by The New York Times.

At the counter

The cases hold the Keys’ best: grouper, snapper, hogfish, king mackerel and swordfish, alongside lobster tails, stone crab claws, Key West pink and royal red shrimp, conch, clams and scallops—even caviar. The kitchen makes ceviche, smoked fish dip, seafood salads and dipping sauces fresh daily, and sells chowders, crab cakes and lobster roll kits.

Cooked to order

Pick your seafood and the market will cook it on the premises. Staff will also peel and devein shrimp, steam lobster and shrimp, split tails and crack stone crab for you to take home.

  • Shipping: nationwide FedEx delivery and overnight shipping through the online store
  • Special orders: a dedicated special order menu is available

Hours aren’t listed on the homepage, so check the contact page or call before you go.