Seafood, Lobster Rolls
Mystic Lobster
Mystic Lobster Roll Company Key West brings Maine-style lobster rolls, fresh seafood, lobster tacos, chowder, mac and ch
Menu & reservations ↗Dock-to-dish seafood in the old Singleton Fish House on the Key West seaport: conch chowder, raw bar oysters and a 4 to 7 p.m. daily happy hour.
About the restaurant
Conch Republic Seafood Company fills the old Singleton Fish House and Ice Plant, where Key West shrimpers once unloaded, processed and shipped thousands of pounds of Key West pink shrimp. The original concrete floors, grates and salvaged wood remain, and the Singleton sign still hangs over the stage. Today it’s a laid-back waterfront eatery overlooking the seaport and marina.
The focus is dock-to-dish seafood with conch and Caribbean flavors. The raw bar offers oysters and clams raw or steamed in the house clam broth, plus Key West pink peel-and-eat shrimp. Starters include cracked conch with orange horseradish marmalade, Bahamian-style conch fritters and smoked fish dip. The award-winning conch chowder and bacon-wrapped stuffed shrimp are signatures, alongside coriander-crusted tuna, Caribbean-spiced mahi and lobster tail. Save room for key lime pie or the prize-winning strawberry tempura.
Call ahead to confirm closing time before an evening visit.