Clemente’s Trolley Pizzaria - Key West Brick Oven Pizza

Clemente’s Trolley Pizzaria brings wood-fired artisan pizza, Italian comfort food, fresh salads, beer, wine, and house-made desserts to 516 Fleming Street in Old Town Key West. Set inside a restored historic trolley car, this casual pizza stop blends brick oven cooking with one of the most memorable restaurant settings in Key West.

The menu highlights thin-crust brick oven pizzas, Sicilian-style thick-crust slices, fresh mozzarella, imported ricotta, homemade marinara, roasted vegetables, meatball and ricotta combinations, Honey Bacon pizza, Meat Lovers pizza, Margherita pizza, Supreme pizza, Eggplant Parm pizza, pasta dishes, antipasto, burrata, meatballs, chicken lollipops, Caesar salad, roasted beet salad, cannoli, tiramisu, ricotta cake, gelato, wine, draft beer, bottled beer, and nonalcoholic beverages. Gluten-free pizza options are also available, making Clemente’s a strong choice for pizza lovers with different dining needs.

Located just a short walk from Duval Street and the Historic Seaport, Clemente’s works well for lunch, dinner, casual date nights, family meals, takeout, delivery, and quick pizza stops while exploring Old Town. Guests looking for brick oven pizza, Italian favorites, fresh salads, cannoli, wine, beer, and a one-of-a-kind trolley restaurant setting will find a distinctive Florida Keys dining experience built around flavor, atmosphere, and local character.