Clemente’s Trolley Pizzaria - Key West Brick Oven Pizza

Clemente’s Trolley Pizzaria | Wood-Fired Brick Oven Pizza in Key West

Clemente’s Trolley Pizzaria elevates pizza culture in Key West, FL, serving wood-fired, artisan pies from a fully restored historic trolley car on Fleming Street. Recognized as TripAdvisor’s #1 pizza restaurant in Key West, this unique dining experience blends Italian tradition with the lively character of Old Town. A blazing 900-degree brick oven creates signature crusts with rustic char, airy texture, and authentic Neapolitan-style flavor.

The menu showcases distinctive combinations executed with masterful precision. Favorite selections include sweet-meets-savory Honey Bacon with layers of caramelized notes, the hearty Meat Lovers, and a thick-cut Sicilian-style option that offers a satisfying, deep-crust alternative. Another standout creation, the eggplant parm ricotta pizza, features crispy, breaded eggplant paired with rich ricotta and house herbs, demonstrating the kitchen’s inventive approach to classic Italian influences.

Starters broaden the experience with playful and elevated interpretations, such as Chicken Lollipops inspired by traditional wings, while fresh salads feature bold flavors like roasted beets paired with sharp vinaigrettes and peppery greens. Weekend specials, including popular lasagna rolls, highlight the culinary team’s versatility beyond the pizza paddle.

For a finishing touch, the dessert selection delivers true Italian authenticity. House-made cannoli filled to order with sweet ricotta and the timeless tiramisu layered with espresso-soaked ladyfingers provide an indulgent finale. Gluten-free pizza options ensure the experience accommodates every kind of diner.

With its vintage trolley setting and vibrant island atmosphere, Clemente’s Trolley Pizzaria remains an essential wood-fired brick oven pizza destination in the Florida Keys, offering culinary craft with an unforgettable sense of place.