Angelina’s Pizzeria Key West - Hand-Tossed Pizza on Duval

Angelina’s Pizzeria serves hand-tossed pizza, slices, subs, pasta, salads, and late-night delivery from its longtime home at 208 Duval Street in the Rick’s and Durty Harry’s complex. Located in the center of Old Town nightlife near Greene Street, Sloppy Joe’s, live music bars, and Duval Street attractions, this casual Key West pizza stop is built for quick lunches, easy dinners, late-night bites, takeout, delivery, and classic Duval Street people-watching.

The menu focuses on fresh, satisfying pizza made with daily handcrafted crust, rich sauce, premium cheese, and a wide range of meat, seafood, vegetable, and gluten-free options. Guests can order whole pies, single slices, build-your-own pizzas, loaded specialty pizzas, calzones, pasta plates, subs, garlic bread, mozzarella sticks, and crisp salads. Popular choices include cheese slices, pepperoni slices, Hawaiian pizza, veggie pizzas, meat lover’s pies, Angelina’s Loaded pizza, chicken parm subs, meatball subs, lasagna, spaghetti, and gluten-free personal pizzas.

Open daily from late morning into the early morning hours, Angelina’s is especially popular with visitors staying downtown, bar-hoppers, musicians, service industry workers, and anyone looking for dependable late-night pizza in Key West. Delivery runs late, making it a convenient option for hotel rooms, vacation rentals, homes, and businesses around the island.

The pizzeria also adds local character with outdoor seating, arcade games, Duval Street energy, and the Sit With Kit podcast hosted by Kit Carson, known as the Earl of Pizza. From a quick slice between attractions to a full pie after midnight, Angelina’s Pizzeria remains one of Key West’s most recognizable casual pizza stops.