Angelina’s Pizzeria Key West - Hand-Tossed Pizza on Duval

Angelina’s Pizzeria Key West – Hand-Tossed Pizza on Duval Street

Angelina’s Pizzeria has served handcrafted slices on the buzzing 200 block of Duval Street for over 30 years, delivering a classic slice-shop experience in the center of Old Town nightlife. Known for hand-tossed dough prepared daily, rich house-made sauce, and layers of premium cheese, this late-night staple has become a legendary stop for locals, musicians, and visitors looking to refuel after a night out. The menu gives hungry guests everything from towering Meat Lover’s pies loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, and bacon, to build-your-own creations packed with fresh vegetables or savory toppings.

Open every day from 11 AM until the early morning hours, Angelina’s Pizzeria Key West remains a go-to choice for lunch crowds, casual dinners, and late-night munchies, especially for anyone bar-hopping between Rick’s Entertainment Complex and neighboring Old Town hotspots. Beyond its iconic slices, the pizzeria offers hearty subs, calzones, pasta plates, and crisp salads, each crafted with the same focus on bold, flavorful ingredients.

Angelina’s Pizzeria also stands out as one of the few spots offering late-night delivery, bringing pizza directly to hotel rooms, live music venues, and homes across the island. Guests who stick around enjoy shaded outdoor seating with a turtle pond, vintage arcade games, and classic Duval Street people-watching. The front bench is home to the Sit With Kit podcast, hosted by Kit Carson—the self-proclaimed “Earl of Pizza”—where island characters, musicians, and longtime locals share stories that showcase the eccentric spirit of Key West.

From daytime slices between adventures to post-party bites after midnight, Angelina’s Pizzeria delivers one of the most iconic and satisfying late night pizza Key West experiences. One taste of its freshly crafted pies explains why this Duval Street favorite continues to be known as the best slice on the Rock.