Caribbean House - Authentic Key West B&B in Bahama Village

Caribbean House Bed & Breakfast delivers a classic Key West bed and breakfast Bahama Village experience at one of the island’s most culturally rich addresses: 226 Petronia Street. This intimate, ten-room retreat provides an inviting tropical refuge only two blocks from Duval Street, offering effortless access to Blue Heaven, Santiago’s Bodega, and other Bahama Village favorites. Guests enjoy a peaceful location steeped in local heritage while remaining within walking distance of Mallory Square, Fort Zachary Taylor Beach, Hemingway House, and the Southernmost Point.

The ten guest rooms, styled with bright Caribbean influence, each accommodate two visitors and feature plush pillow-top beds in king, queen, or twin layouts. Rooms include private bathrooms, boutique bath amenities, individual climate control, HD televisions, mini-refrigerators, hairdryers, complimentary high-speed Wi-Fi, daily housekeeping, and access to the balcony surrounding the building. The property’s signature white clapboard façade, pastel trim, lush palms, and quirky mileage markers create a picturesque Old Town backdrop ideal for a laid-back tropical stay.

A complimentary expanded continental breakfast is served daily from 8:30 AM to 10:30 AM in the open-air tiki courtyard. Fresh eggs, waffles, pastries, yogurt, and complimentary mimosas set the tone for a relaxed morning, while an elevated balcony offers a scenic spot to enjoy lemon water and admire local artwork. An on-site boutique gift shop features handcrafted items inspired by Bahama Village culture.

Caribbean House provides tremendous value compared to other historic Old Town Key West lodging, including rare off-street parking for $25/day (limited availability), bike rentals available, and seasonal rates that vary by date and availability. With its walkable setting near legendary attractions and its reputation as an affordable Duval Street B&B, this property stands out as a favored basecamp for romantic escapes, cultural explorations, and island adventures.

For current room options, rates, and direct reservations, use the Reserve a Room button above.