Andrew’s Inn - Boutique Guesthouse in Old Town Key West

Andrew's Inn stands as the premier Old Town Key West boutique hotel, occupying a coveted location in historic Old Town, mere steps from Duval Street and directly adjacent to the legendary Hemingway House. This intimate six-room historic guesthouse blends island relaxation with unparalleled walkability to Key West's most treasured attractions. Recognition follows every aspect of Andrew's Inn. The property holds TripAdvisor's #1 specialty lodging ranking and boasts a Certificate of Excellence. Environmental stewardship earns the prestigious Two-Palm Florida Green Lodging designation and TripAdvisor GreenLeader status, making Andrew's Inn the ideal selection for eco-conscious travelers seeking sustainable Key West accommodations.

Each stay includes complimentary perks valued at over $100 daily: fresh tropical breakfast served poolside each morning in a lush garden courtyard, Key West's happiest happy hour featuring signature cocktails and local brews, and free bicycle usage for every guest, enabling exploration of the island like a local. Unlike cramped Duval Street hotels, Andrew's Inn's shimmering pool sits surrounded by mature palm trees, fragrant hibiscus, and colorful bougainvillea. This hidden paradise invites guests to mingle and unwind. Restored Conch architecture showcases traditional Bahamian design elements, local artwork, and breezy verandas that capture historic Key West living.

Six climate-controlled rooms serve as sanctuaries of comfort, each featuring premium NECTAR mattresses with luxury linens for restorative sleep, smart TVs and high-speed Wi-Fi for entertainment and connectivity, in-room coffee stations and bar fridges, tower fans and traditional louvered windows for authentic tropical breezes, plus local artwork and handcrafted furnishings celebrating Key West culture. Guests leave cars behind, as the location provides a 5-minute walk to Mallory Square sunsets, Sloppy Joe's Bar, Key West Lighthouse, and Bahama Village's vibrant galleries and restaurants. Quiet residential setting ensures peaceful nights away from Duval Street crowds.

Anniversary celebrations, romantic getaways, or alternatives to generic Key West hotels find their answer at Andrew's Inn. With only six rooms, personalized service and authentic charm surpass larger properties. Seasoned travelers return, calling it their home away from home. Check availability for upcoming Key West vacations and book direct for best rates and flexible cancellation policies. Andrew's Inn delivers the most celebrated boutique guesthouse experience in Old Town Key West—where historic charm meets modern eco-luxury.